Thanksgiving: The Story We Were Told — And the One We Now Know

by Jessica J Baldovinos

🦃 Thanksgiving: The Story We Were Told — And the One We Now Know:
 

When I was a child, Thanksgiving was presented as a warm beginning — a story of unity, kindness, and shared meals. I was told that the Pilgrims and Native Americans gathered around a long wooden table, laughing, cooking, offering peace, and breaking bread together. 🍂🤝

At school, we colored turkeys, traced our hands into feathers, cut buckle hats out of construction paper, and acted out plays where everyone smiled. 🎨🖐️
We were taught that Thanksgiving was the first moment of gratitude shared between cultures — a symbol of peace, new beginnings, and generosity. It was gentle. It was beautiful.
It was easy to believe.


🔍 But we grew up — and history followed us into adulthood.

As adults, we learned a different story — one supported by evidence, research, and accounts that were not included in childhood classrooms. 📚
What began in textbooks as friendship was also layered with displacement, disease, colonization, and the eventual destruction of Indigenous tribes and cultures.

Yes, there may have been a shared meal — but it wasn’t the origin of peace.
It was a moment inside a much larger, painful timeline.
A timeline filled with power imbalance, broken treaties, and violence.

The holiday we were handed was shaped to feel good.
But it left out truths that deserve acknowledgment. 🗣️

And once you learn, you don’t unlearn.


🧍‍♀️ Where I stand now...

I don’t personally enjoy celebrating a holiday rooted in half-truths and selective storytelling.
I can be thankful for my life, my family, and my blessings without needing a date on a calendar to validate that.

Yet — I still show up.
Not for the myth.
But for my family. 🤍

I sit at the table not to honor a polished narrative, but to honor the present moment — the laughter, the meals, and the time we will never get back. 🕯️
Sometimes we participate in things we don’t fully agree with — because connection matters too.


🌿 The deeper truth: Gratitude shouldn’t be seasonal.

For many, Thanksgiving is a pause. A reminder. A chance to reflect.
But gratitude was never meant for one Thursday in November.

We can be thankful every morning we wake up. 🌅
Every meal we eat. 🍽️
Every hug we receive. 🤗
Every hardship we survive. 🧗‍♀️
Every unexpected joy. ✨

Gratitude is not a holiday —
it’s a lifestyle, a mindset, a daily practice.

A choice.
Every day. Not once a year.


If we choose to continue Thanksgiving, let it be honest, human, and grounded in truth.
Let it be a day for awareness, remembrance, and appreciation — not myth.
Let it reflect growth, not convenience.

We honor the past by acknowledging it fully.
We honor gratitude by living it daily. 🌾

Not because a story told us to —

but because awareness, truth, and thankfulness deserve more than a holiday. 💛

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message